Monday, August 8, 2016

A Blind Eye

Published August 3, 2016 in Tulare County's Foothills Sun-Gazette


     Driving to work last week, I heard a snippet of Michele Obama’s DNC speech replayed on Valley Public Radio.  One sentence caught the attention of liberals and conservatives alike. 
     
     Referring to the White House, she said, “Every morning I wake up in a house that was built by slaves.” Most of us didn’t know that small but incredibly relevant fact, but when she spoke it, a more complex version of history began to emerge.  Huh. Really?  Wow….
 
     A second layer of wonder sat quietly below the first one:  that this woman with slave ancestors could hold those facts together in her mind and not flinch.  That she and her half-Black husband (whose Kenyan ancestors were not part of our American slave history but who has been treated by some as if he still wore leg chains,) have risen to the position of highest responsibility in the world.
           
     What I realized after hearing her utter that sentence is that she has not turned a blind eye to the complexity of her world:  she knowingly inhabits a culture and a social position dependent on the backs of other people who, in reality, have little opportunity for recognition of their contributions or to enjoy the proper fruits.  Despite the complexity, she does not blink.
           
     The same could be said about Barack’s Kansas-born Anglo mother, Ann Dunham:  she couldn’t turn a blind eye to the racism of mainland America, or even that found in polyglot Hawaii.  Barack’s mother, who loved his father and fought for her son, worked for the equitable development of rural people in foreign places until she died of untended health problems.  If we’d had Obamacare then, she might have lived to see this miracle she partly created.  No wonder our current President could not turn a blind eye on health care reform: he didn’t have one.
           
     Last week I also found a great story about how a blind eye gains its sight.  I was working to edit passages from Rick Wartzman’s incredible book about the burning of John Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath for my volume on Agriculture and the Common Good.  In 1939 the Associated Farmers, claiming the book was lewd, even obscene (hence the title of Wartzman’s book, Obscene in the Extreme) convinced the Kern County Board of Supervisors to pass a resolution banning the book, then staged its burning at the hands of an Okie farmworker.  The book’s real violation was not so much offensive language, however, as was its unveiling of an ungodly fact of Valley life.  It called our blind eyes on the carpet.
           
     Steinbeck started Grapes with his eyes partly shielded, hoping to retain his objectivity like he did in In Dubious Battle, a book inspired by the Cotton Strike of 1933.  He’d been shown the differences in the Dust Bowl refugees’ living conditions between ditch-bank Hoovervilles and the government labor camps, an important part of the eventual story.  His notes were copious, his files were thick; the story threatened to overwhelm him with its magnitude.  He couldn’t see how to tell the story rightly – until the rains came.
           
     In the early months of 1938, the Kings and Kaweah Rivers overflowed their banks, flooding the low places where workers lived.  He told a friend that he couldn’t just write about it, he had to do something.  He drove to Visalia and joined a small group of people rescuing families from flooded tents and cardboard shacks, bringing food and dry clothing, working sopping wet day and night without food himself to help those who were much hungrier and more desperately tired than he was.  It was that experience that ripped any remaining film of “objectivity” from his eyes and untethered his pen.  The heavy manuscript of The Grapes of Wrath went to the publisher before the year was over.
           
     “Turning a blind eye” on difficult problems is something we all do, at least temporarily.  Nationally, many of us are doing it with the facts undermining Donald Trump’s claim to fame: his bankruptcies, labor abuses, his cut-and-run approach to financial obligations, his refusal to face the community impacts of his personal business practices.  Locally, we cheer those who proclaim they can fix our water shortage by building more reservoirs, turning a blind eye to the lack of rainfall to fill them, the evidence for climate change and the lousy cost-benefit ratios.
           
     But I think we need to wake up to the reality behind the conflicting claims and simple solutions.  We need to take a good hard look at the facts nationwide and in our own region, before we find ourselves sopping wet, cold and hungry, knee-deep in the mud of truth. 
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trudy Wischemann is a writer whose pen often champs at the bit.  You can send her your blindness confessions c/o P.O. Box 1374, Lindsay CA 93247 or leave a comment below.

No comments:

Post a Comment