Showing posts with label Chris Brewer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chris Brewer. Show all posts

Monday, September 25, 2017

Preserving the Future

Published in edited form Sept. 20, 2017 in Tulare County's Foothills Sun-Gazette


     While in Dunsmuir two weeks ago, I overheard something wise from an acquaintance, who’d been told “You can drag the past around with you like a dead horse, but you can never bring it back to life.”  I was struck by the truth of the imagery, and put it in my mental pocket for future use.
           
     But something else I brought home from Dunsmuir convinced me that the past is an ineradicable part of the present, as well as necessary for the future.  It is a small book on Dunsmuir, one of the “Images of America” series published by Arcadia Publishing Co.  I fell in love with these books when I worked at the Book Garden in Exeter ten years ago, and exactly for this reason:  they show us – literally, in photographs with captions - the connections between our past and our present.  They help us understand what might be possible in the future.
           
     As a carpenter’s daughter, I have a natural fascination for how things are built.  My father builds houses, and I have watched the process from building forms for pouring the concrete foundation to the last row of shingles along the roof’s peak.  I watched him build community, too, from co-operatively constructing a boat-launch/clubhouse on an edge of Puget Sound to forming a sewer district intended to keep us from polluting that body of water.  I watched as our primitive roads lined with wooded lots became neighborhoods during the post-war 1950’s.  My fascination with how things are built now extends to towns.
           
     Like many towns, Dunsmuir’s development was defined by the railroad, which was spurred by outside corporate interests to convey coal from British Columbia to San Francisco.  In turn, the railroad promoted Dunsmuir as a tourist resort, as well as carrying the products of surrounding forests to distant markets.  But it was the development of the automobile that brought prosperity to the little town, which seemed to thrive when Highway 99 ran down its main street.  Despite fires, heavy snows and avalanches, and flooding of the Sacramento River repeatedly reshaping the facts of Dunsmuir’s life, the little town has re-built on its past, retaining a sense of authenticity.
           
     And of course it’s the people who make that possible.  Ron McCloud, who co-authored the book with Deborah Harton, owns the True Value hardware store on the main street, which is part museum, with shining wood floors as well as inventory to supply everything you’d need to live there (visit www.dunsmuirhardware.com to see for yourself!)  Across the street, wedged between cafes, is a thrift store run by third- and fourth-generation Dunsmuirites whose profits support single mothers in need.   There’s a record shop/book store aimed at us Boomers, multiple shops featuring artists’ and craftspersons’ wares, and a storefront for the local watershed preservation organization.  There’s a dispensary for medical marijuana across from the Amtrak station.  And there’s a noon signal horn every day that becomes an emergency warning when it blows 5 times in succession.
           
     When I mentioned Ron McCloud to a friend here, he said “Oh, he’s like our Chris Brewer.”  Having worked for Chris and Sally at the Book Garden, I can say “yes.”  Chris has managed to bring the powerhouse of history into the preservation of the future in Exeter.  I think the example of both men is worth noting. But it takes a host of people dedicated to the community’s well-being to connect the past to the present – and that’s what preserves the future of our small towns.  Let us join hands.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trudy Wischemann is a community development researcher who writes.  You can send her your town development stories c/o P.O. Box 1374, Lindsay CA 93247 or leave a comment below.

Thursday, September 17, 2015

Property Rights and Community Wrongs

Published Sept. 16, 2015 in Tulare County's Foothills Sun-Gazette


            “Search for a congenial relation between man and land has gone on throughout recorded time, for that relation largely shapes the relation between man and man.”  Paul Schuster Taylor, 1979
 
     “What’s your book about?” people ask when I tell them I’m working on one.  I usually say “agriculture and the common good,” sometimes adding a few items lodged under that umbrella like “small farms,” “water,” and “sustainability.”  But the thread running through it all is land tenure.

     “Land tenure” is not a term most people use, although it applies to every single one of us.  It means the system that determines peoples’ access to land, which is the source of all wealth as well as subsistence, and the subcategories of relationships determined by that system.

            In this country, the system of private property determines individuals’ access to land except where government control has interceded (like school grounds or Yosemite National Park, for instance.)  The subcategories in our system are “landed,” “tenant,” and “landless” or “homeless.”  The concept of private property is so important to our entire socio-political-economic system that we take it for granted, almost god-given.  To criticize private property here, even if the intent is to help, is like burning the flag.  

            What’s good about private property (i.e., individual ownership,) particularly when we’re talking about land, however, isn’t always good for the community. One of the worst things for any given community is when some of its land (or most, or all, as in "company towns,") is owned by people who do not live within it, often referred to as “absentee ownership.”  What’s wrong about it is that decisions for the land’s use by the absentee owner are made in a vacuum of knowledge about the community’s needs and beyond the community’s ability to influence those decisions, to encourage or coerce the owner to care about the effects of those decisions on people within the community or the community as a whole.

            Last week’s paper carried a wonderful example of the importance of land tenure in a beautifully written letter to the editor by Chris and Sally Brewer regarding the closure of Exeter’s True Value Hardware.  The letter pointed to a cause the previous week’s news article had skimmed over lightly:  the landowner’s decision to raise the rent 40%, with two weeks’ notice.  It’s the kind of action landowners take when they want to remove the tenant and do not have cause to evict. 

            The Brewers then went on to suggest a motive - to get a tax write-off for having an empty building - and to flush out the implications of that for the community (lost sales tax revenues, the impacts on other businesses of having a large empty building downtown) as well as for the business owners themselves (lost source of income and community identity.)  They then went on to express the hope that “the building owner who started this self-centered and thoughtless action realizes the extent and harm his actions have caused good people and a good community.”

            That last sentence might have some impact if the current owners are local.  The Brewers’ letter did not name or identify the location of the current owners, only that the former owners (who also had owned the hardware business housed there) sold the building several years ago.  This is simply to say that I do not know if the current owners are absentee, or simply acting like it.  My experiences here in Lindsay document that local owners can be as oblivious to the community’s welfare as absentee owners can.

            But it’s a question we should ask.  Who will look out for the needs of the community when the landowners of its spaces live too far away to know or care?
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Trudy Wischemann is a community development researcher who writes.  You can send your empty building nightmares to her c/o P.O. Box 1374, Lindsay CA 93247